What exactly is Darwinian evolution — and does the evidence truly support it? Critique of Darwinism takes you on a rigorous, multi-layered exploration of evolutionary theory as it’s commonly presented in science education today. From the fossil record and molecular biology to textbook case studies and the so-called “icons of evolution,” this course examines the data with a critical lens and highlights the philosophical assumptions that often go unchallenged.

You’ll investigate why classic examples used to support Darwinism — such as the peppered moth, Darwin’s finches, and Haeckel’s embryos — have been questioned or debunked by scientists. You'll also delve into deeper issues: Is natural selection really the creative force it’s claimed to be? Why do some scientists argue that Darwinism functions more as a worldview than a testable theory? And are there more coherent alternatives that better explain what we see in nature?

Whether you're a student, educator, or curious thinker, this course will equip you with the tools to think critically, assess the evidence objectively, and navigate the evolution debate with clarity and confidence.

“The course is well-suited for addressing all aspects of Darwinism, especially with its coverage of both past and present perspectives. It clearly highlights the philosophical issues involved, with each topic explored in dedicated lessons. It's definitely a valuable guide for pioneers and anyone navigating the growing challenges in this area. It has also played a significant role in my academic journey by providing greater Islamic insight on the subject.”

Abdullah Teladia

“I would say this course is essential for anyone exposed to the topic of evolution, as it academically uncovers the misconceptions promoted by modern science. The tutor is masha'Allah clearly knowledgeable and well-versed in the field. This course also builds on the foundation laid by another similar course offered at Rayyan.”

Student Testimonial

Course Curriculum

    1. Introducing Evolutionary Theory

    2. Lesson 1 Quiz

    1. Critique of Common Descent

    2. Lesson 2 Quiz

    1. Critique of Natural Selection

    2. Lesson 3 Quiz

    1. Conclusion

    2. Lesson 4 Quiz

    1. AQD501 Quiz

    2. Feedback Form

About this course

  • 3 hours of video content
  • Elective Course
  • Rayyan Courses' Subscription

What will you learn in this course?

This course aims to provide the student with the following outcomes:

  • Examine the mystery of the Cambrian Explosion and why it poses a major challenge to the gradualist model of Darwinian evolution.

  • Understand and critique key textbook examples, including the peppered moths, Darwin's finches, and four-winged fruit flies, often cited as evidence for natural selection.

  • Explore the critique of the homology concept, and why genetic and anatomical similarities don’t always support common ancestry.

  • Analyze the critique of Haeckel's embryos, including the history of scientific fraud and its persistence in modern education.

  • Identify the philosophical assumptions underlying Darwinism, including the shift from methodological to metaphysical naturalism.

  • Develop a critical framework to assess evolutionary claims, uncover philosophical assumptions, and consider alternative models such as intelligent design.

Need help with paying for your course?

Send us an email at [email protected]

Instructor

Maulana Usman Ali

Course Instructor

Maulana Usman Ali is an Alimiyyah graduate who taught both Islamic and Secular Sciences at various institutes of learning. Concurrently, a Chartered Senior Specialist in Biomedical Sciences and Section Leader in Haematology with clinical laboratory and research roles, and a PhD candidate and an Associate Lecturer at the University of Portsmouth.

Explore other courses in our subscription!

View more courses